In the Preface to The Principles of Quantum Mechanics, before asking the reader to dive into a roiling sea of complex equations, P.A.M. Dirac gets right to the heart of what makes quantum theory difficult to communicate in non-mathematical terms: quantum theory cannot be "built up from physical concepts known to the student, which cannot be explained adequately in words at all." In the similarly named book published the same year, The Physical Principles of the Quantum Theory (1930), Werner Heisenberg elaborates on that point:
It is not surprising that our language should be incapable of describing the processes occurring within the atoms, for...it was invented to describe the experiences of daily life, and these consist only of processes involving exceedingly large numbers of atoms. Furthermore, it is very difficult to modify our language so that it will be able to describe these atomic processes, for words can only describe things of which we can form mental pictures, and this ability, too, is a result of daily experience. Fortunately, mathematics is not subject to this limitation, and it has been possible to invent a mathematical scheme --- the quantum theory---which seems entirely adequate for the treatment of atomic processes; for visualisation, however, we must content ourselves with two incomplete analogies---the wave picture and the corpuscular picture. It is a trite saying that "things cannot be pushed too far," yet they may be justifiably used to describe things for which our language has no words.
This incomprehensibility tag has proven to be enduring. More than three decades later, at the start of the third volume to his Lectures on Physics, Richard Feynman says that:
"Quantum mechanics" is the description of the behavior of matter and light in all its detail and, in particular, of the happening on an atomic scale. Things on a very small scale behave like nothing that you have any direct experience about. They do not behave like waves, they do not behave like particles, they do not behave like clouds, or billiard balls, or weights on springs, or like anything that you have ever seen.
The above statements suggest that writing a popular exposition of this conceptually slippery physics is a lost cause, doomed to failure from the start. And yet, ironically, many of the key figures in the quantum revolution---including not only Heisenberg and Feynman but also Albert Einstein, Niels Bohr, and Erwin Schrödinger---not to mention numerous other top-notch physicists up to the present time, have devoted considerable thought and energy to explaining the key quantum mysteries to us, by words and pictures.
Let's take as our brief example here the mystery of wave-particle duality, brilliantly and clearly explicated by Feynman in his Lectures on Physics with words and visuals plus a few simple equations. In his lecture devoted to quantum mechanics, Feynman borrows from two famous sources: a well-known actual experiment, the "double-slit experiment," executed by Thomas Young in 1801 to establish the wave properties of light and a double-slit thought experiment concocted by Einstein at the close of the famous Solvay Congress in Brussels, 1927, to argue for the incompleteness of quantum mechanics. In his quantum lecture, Feynman gives this hallowed experiment his own special twist to capture the strangeness of the wave-particle quantum properties of light.
Feynman's thought experiment is a four-part invention. For the first part, Feynman asks us to imagine a machine gun that shoots bullets at the same speed over a sweeping arc. Beyond the gun at some distance we are to also imagine an armor-plated wall with two slits wide enough for bullets to pass through from any angle. Beyond the wall, we are to imagine a backstop of wood. On that wall we are to imagine a small box filled with sand, the bullet catcher, which can be moved up and down along the backstop (also the x-axis for graphing purposes).
Imagining this experimental arrangement much less its execution by solely relying on a verbal mental picture would be nearly impossible. Feynman thus provides us a real picture (Figure 1). In Feynman's diagram, the left half visualizes the components of the experiment and the actions carried out during its execution, while the right half displays the corresponding probabilities in graphical and equation form---a beautiful amalgamation of verbal thought experiment, visuals, and math.
For the experimental execution, we are to imagine the gun spraying a random stream of bullets at the wall. Some percentage pass through the slits and strike the backstop. An even smaller percentage land in the sand-filled detector. The probability of a bullet passing through one of the slits and arriving in the detector is simply the number of bullets in the detector divided by the total number of bullets striking the backstop over a certain time interval. We are to repeat this experiment many times, each time changing the position of the detector along the vertical x-axis. If we perform the experiment enough times, we will find that the plot of the probability for the bullets striking any position along the backstop follows the curve shown beyond the backstop to the far right (c).
We are next to close up slit 2 and determine the probability curve for slit 1 alone, then do the same for slit 2. That creates the
In part two, Feynman changes the experiment and substitutes waves of water for the machine gun bullets, a wave absorber for the backstop, and a detector of wave height (analogous to energy) for the former bullet catcher. The image in Figure 2a shows the interference of the waves that occurs after they pass through the two slits in the wall.
The smoothly fluctuating plot of the wave intensity measured by the detector is shown in Figure 2c, created by the collision and resulting interference of the two waves emerging from the slits as depicted in (a). But upon closing slit 2, we obtain the smooth intensity curve (
In the third part, Feynman changes the experiment yet again, substituting an electron gun for the wave source and a Geiger counter for the detector, and switching from the world we all can observe to the microworld. The wall and backstop are simply a metal plate. When we perform the modified experiment, even though we are shooting individual electrons from the gun, the curves and equations are exactly the same as those for the wave (compare graphs in Figures 2 and 3). This experiment is analogous to the wave experiment in that they both produce graphs and equations consistent with wave behavior, and it is dis-analogous in that particles are being shot at the wall, not waves. In Feynman's words, "The electrons arrive in lumps, like particles, and the probability of arrival of these lumps is distributed like the distribution of the intensity of a wave. It is in this sense that an electron behaves 'sometimes like a particle and sometimes like a wave.'"
In Figure 3, it seems unassailably logical to claim that each electron passes through either slit 1 or slit 2, but not both, but the simple statement "A or B" means something completely different in the microworld. As Susskind and Friedman repeatedly remind their readers in Quantum Mechanics, "real quantum mechanics is not so much about particles and waves but the nonclassical logical principles that govern their behavior."
To illustrate the difference at its most extreme, in the last part of his explanatory narrative, Feynman has us repeat the electron experiment except with a slight wrinkle: into the experimental setup in Figure 3 we are to insert right behind the wall at (a), between slits 1 and 2, a light source that can detect electrons so that we can actually detect whether any given electron has actually passed through slit 1 or 2. In this experimental arrangement, lo and behold, the probability curve is not that shown in Figure 3c, but the same as the particle-like behavior for the machine gun experiment with the random spray of bullets shown in Figure 1c. This last thought experiment illustrates Heisenberg's uncertainty principle: observing the movement of an electron changes its behavior in some essential way. In Feynman's words "We must conclude that when he look at the electrons the distribution of them on the screen [backstop] is different than when we do not look."
Note that, unlike Figures 1 and 2, Figure 3 does not display the trajectory of the electrons as they leave the gun, pass through the slit, and strike the backdrop, nor does Feynman really discuss it. That region is blank, for a reason. How can one visualize the path of something that is simultaneously like a wave and particle? Feynman wisely does not try. This figure is an analogy for the wave-particle behavior of microscopic projectiles according to quantum theory.
Feynman's lecture on the double-slit thought experiment ends here, but Feynman did elsewhere extend this thought experiment with an improbable-sounding solution to the wave-particle problem related to particle trajectory that works amazingly well mathematically while leaving common sense far behind. As expressed by contemporary physicist Brian Greene, each electron "traverses every possible trajectory simultaneously...It goes in a nice orderly way through the left slit. It simultaneously also goes in a nice orderly way through the right slit...It goes on a long journey to the Andromeda galaxy before turning back and passing through the left slit on its way to the screen." And so on through every possible path! This fantastical solution is still very much physics at the bleeding edge, as Greene cautions, since no one has yet experimentally established whether or not Feynman's "sum over histories approach" is "merely a clever mathematical contrivance that gets the right answer."
Feynman's double-slit thought experiments reward readers in two ways: we can gain insight into the quantum world with minimal mathematics and glimpse the mind of an ingenious physicist and visual thinker at work.
This article was written independently of the author's employment at the U.S. Department of Energy's Argonne National Laboratory.
Notes
- P.A.M. Dirac, The Principles of Quantum Mechanics, 4th ed. (Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1958) p. vii.
- Werner Heisenberg, The Physical Principles of the Quantum Theory, translated by Carl Eckhart and Frank C. Hoyt (New York: Dover Publications, 1930) p. 10.
- Richard P. Feynman, Robert B. Leighton, and Matthew Sands, "Quantum Mechanics," in The Feynman Lectures on Physics, Vol. III (Reading, MA: Addison-Wesley Publishing, 1965) p. 1-1.
- Leonard Susskind and Art Friedman, Quantum Mechanics: The Theoretical Minimum (New York: Basic Books, 2014), p. 236.
- Brian Greene, The Elegant Universe: Superstrings, Hidden Dimensions, and the Quest for the Ultimate Universe (New York: W.W. Norton, 1999), p. 110.
